Grate your cheese, sprinkle generously in the middle of one tortilla. With a pizza knife, cut a second tortilla in strips. Lay strips in a haphazard criss-cross pattern over the cheese, leaving space for eyes. Place two round edible objects for eyes and cook like a normal quesadilla. We fire up our stovetop griddle (medium heat) and cook until cheese is melted.
Our eyes are made from two pieces of Count Chocula cereal. It was the only thing we had around the house!
I originally got this idea off of Pinterest from this cute blog.